Skip to main content

Table 4 Multinomial logistic regression examining the relationship between journal characteristics and the coverage of GAI usage guidelines among the 200 top SJR ranked journals

From: Generative artificial intelligence (GAI) usage guidelines for scholarly publishing: a cross-sectional study of medical journals

 

Top SJR ranked journals (n = 200)

 

No guidelines

External guidelines only

Own guidelines only

Own and external guidelines

Journal characteristics

 

Coef.

95% CI

P value

Coef.

95% CI

P value

Coef.

95% CI

P value

  

Coverage of author guidelines

SJR score

Ref.

0.47

(-0.05, 0.98)

0.08

0.38

(-0.18, 0.94)

0.18

0.45

(-0.07, 0.96)

0.09

Region

          

 Northern America

Ref.

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 Western Europe

Ref.

-0.92

(-2.49,0.64)

0.25

0.22

(-1.69, 2.13)

0.82

0.51

(-0.84, 1.87)

0.46

 Other regions#

Ref.

-1.48

(-4.41, 1.46)

0.32

-12.17

(-976.04, 951.70)

0.98

-12.12

(-244.87, 220.64)

0.92

Focus area

          

 General medicine

Ref.

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 Specialty areas

Ref.

0.78

(-0.74, 2.31)

0.31

1.54

(-0.91, 3.99)

0.22

1.08

(-0.25, 2.41)

0.11

  

Coverage of reviewer guidelines

SJR score

Ref.

0.18

(-0.08, 0.45)

0.18

0.10

(-0.40, 0.60)

0.69

0.24

(-0.03, 0.51)

0.08

Region

          

 Northern America

Ref.

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 Western Europe

Ref.

-0.47

(-1.61, 0.66)

0.41

-0.69

(-3.31, 1.93)

0.60

0.58

(-0.54, 1.71)

0.31

 Other regions#

Ref.

-2.02

(-4.91, 0.86)

0.17

-6.24

(-89.26, 76.79)

0.88

-9.89

(-134.78, 115.01)

0.88

Focus area

          

 General medicine

Ref.

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

 Specialty areas

Ref.

0.45

(-0.73, 1.63)

0.45

7.26

(-53.09, 67.61)

0.81

1.06

(-0.15, 2.28)

0.09

  1. Footnote: Weighted regression results were reported
  2. #Other regions included Africa, Asiatic region, Eastern Europe, Latin America, Middle East, and Pacific region