Skip to main content

Table 4 Comparison of advantages and disadvantages of the different methodological approaches presented

From: Diagnosis of celiac disease on a gluten-free diet: a multicenter prospective quasi-experimental clinical study

 

CD8+ T-cell

IL-2

% TCRγδ+

UBE2L3

Patient requirements

 Strict GFD

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

 GC requirement

Yes

Yes

No

No

 GC duration

3 days

1 day

 Intervention

Minimally invasive

(blood)

Minimally invasive

(blood)

Invasive (upper endoscopy, biopsy)

Minimally invasive

(blood)

 Procedure delay

Minimal

Minimal

Endoscopy waiting list

Minimal

 Visits for sample collection

2 (baseline and day 6)

2 (baseline and 4 h)

1

1

Technical requirements

 Processing time/sample

2.5 h

9 h

3 h

6 h

 Special requirement

Flow cytometer

Ultrasensitive immunoassay platform

Flow cytometer

Real-time PCR

 Minimal sample size for cost-effectiveness

1 patient

10 patients

1 patient

1 patienta

 Time to diagnostic results

6 days

2 daysb

1 day

1–2 daysb

  1. GFD gluten-free diet, GC gluten challenge
  2. aIt may depend on the center of analysis. bThe number of patients for a cost-effective analysis may cause considerable delay